Car insurance after an accident: what happens to your rate?
An accident doesn’t have to mean you’re stuck with a more expensive rate. Here’s how a car accident can affect your insurance, what your options are, and what you can do next.
Does your car insurance go up after an accident?
A car accident often raises your rate, but the amount depends on who was at fault, your driving history, and your carrier. Not every accident leads to the same outcome. Understanding how car accident insurance works can help you know what to expect and what steps to take.
At-fault vs. not-at-fault accidents
If you were found at fault in an accident, your carrier is more likely to adjust your rate than if someone else caused the crash. Not being at fault doesn’t always protect you from a rate change, but it can make a difference. Rules vary by state and carrier, so the outcomes aren’t the same for every driver.
Filing a car accident insurance claim is a separate step from how your rate is set. Making a claim starts the process of getting covered for damages. Whether your rate changes depends on your carrier’s policies, your driving history, and state rules.
Typical premium increases based on severity of accident
Not all accidents affect your rate the same way. The size of your premium increase typically depends on how serious the accident was and whether you were at fault.
- Minor at-fault accident (no injuries): A minor collision involving only property damage may raise your rate by around 20–30%. This is generally the lower end of what most carriers charge after a first at-fault claim.
- Major at-fault accident (with injuries): When an accident results in injuries to others, rate increases of 40% or more are common. The higher the claim amount, the greater the impact on your premium.
- Multiple at-fault accidents: Two or more at-fault accidents in a short period can push your rate significantly higher. Some carriers may also choose not to renew your policy.
How much do rates typically change?
Rate increases after an accident can vary widely. For instance, an at-fault accident can increase premiums between 20% and 73%, depending on the severity of the accident and any injuries. Two drivers with similar histories can see very different changes depending on their carrier, state, and the details of the accident. There’s no single number that applies to everyone.
That’s one reason why it’s important to look for a carrier that has experience working with people with less-than-perfect driving records. One carrier may apply a larger surcharge than another for the same incident. If you want a sense of what you might pay before and after an accident, reviewing average car insurance costs can give you useful context.
How long does an accident affect your rate?
A surcharge from an accident usually applies for a set number of years, then phases out. The exact window depends on your carrier and state. In many cases, the increase is not permanent.
Many drivers worry about being locked into a higher rate for good after an accident. While it’s natural to be concerned about permanently high rates, the outlook isn’t all doom and gloom. The situation – and your rate – often improves over time, especially if you keep a clean record going forward.
What is accident forgiveness car insurance?
Accident forgiveness is a feature some carriers offer that may keep your rate from rising after a first qualifying accident. Not all carriers include it, and the terms differ depending on where you live and who your carrier is. If you’ve been searching for car insurance with accident forgiveness or comparing car insurance accident forgiveness options across carriers, it helps to understand exactly how it works before you decide.
How accident forgiveness works
When a carrier offers accident forgiveness, it can protect your rate from going up after your first at-fault accident. Some carriers include it automatically after you’ve been a customer for a certain period, which can be a nice loyalty perk for staying with the same carrier. Others offer it as an add-on you can purchase for an additional cost.
The terms aren’t the same everywhere. What qualifies as a “first accident,” how long you need to be a customer, and which accidents are covered may vary. Accident forgiveness is not a universal feature, and it’s not a guarantee that nothing will change. However, it can offer an added layer of protection for eligible drivers.
Who may qualify for accident forgiveness
An insurance company will typically look at your recent driving record when deciding eligibility. Drivers with a clean history over a three to five consecutive year period are more likely to qualify. Some carriers offer it as a free loyalty reward, while others offer it as an optional add-on. As of 2026, purchasing an accident forgiveness policy add-on typically costs under $30 per month, which is potentially far less than the rate increase that can follow a first at-fault claim.
Availability also depends on your state and carrier, since not every provider offers the feature in every location. California is widely restricted and many major carriers do not offer accident forgiveness in the state. Connecticut and Massachusetts are also restricted for certain providers. However, most other states allow carriers to offer the benefit, although terms and eligibility may vary by carrier.
If your current carrier doesn’t offer accident forgiveness, that’s a good reason to look for one that does. A different provider may offer it, and you won’t know what options are available to you until you look.
How to keep car insurance affordable after an accident
A rate increase after an accident can feel discouraging, but there are a few steps you can take to get the best possible rate. Here’s where to start.
Review your coverage and deductibles
Adjusting your coverage or deductible can change what you pay each month. A higher deductible usually lowers your monthly premium (the price you pay for your policy). However, it raises your out-of-pocket costs if you need to file a claim. That said, it’s a trade-off that’s worth thinking through carefully.
It also helps to review what types of coverage you’re carrying. Understanding the difference between collision coverage and other coverage types can help you decide what level of protection makes sense for your budget. If you want a broader picture of what’s included in a standard policy, our guide to full coverage car insurance breaks it down clearly.
Options for drivers with less-than-perfect records
If your record isn’t perfect, you still have options. AssuranceAmerica believes that every driver is entitled to a fair rate, including those who have had accidents or violations. No credit check is required to get a quote, and no U.S. ID is required either.
If your accident was serious enough that you’ve been asked to file a financial responsibility form, you may need to learn about SR-22 insurance. An SR-22 is a certificate your carrier files with the state to confirm you have the required coverage. Our agents can help you understand whether you need one and what to do next.
Keeping auto insurance affordable after an accident
A rate change after an accident is common, and often temporary. The most important thing to know is that you have options. Start by reviewing your coverage and deductibles.
If you’re thinking about switching to a carrier that specializes in non-standard auto insurance, AssuranceAmerica makes it simple to get a fast, fair quote in less than 90 seconds. Whether you have a clean record or a few bumps along the way, our licensed agents are here to help you find coverage that works for your situation and your budget. Same-day coverage may be available for eligible drivers, and bilingual support in English and Spanish is available when you need it.
FAQs
It depends on your state and carrier. In many cases, a not-at-fault accident has less impact on your rate than one where you were responsible. Some carriers don’t adjust rates for not-at-fault accidents at all. Others may, depending on your state’s rules and your policy terms. For example, California and Oklahoma have consumer protection laws that specifically prohibit insurers from raising your premium after an accident where you were not at fault. Most other states have no such rule, which means your carrier may still adjust your rate, even if you weren’t responsible for the crash.
Your claim history also plays a role. If you’ve filed multiple claims in a short period, your insurer may view you as a higher-risk driver regardless of fault. A single not-at-fault accident on an otherwise clean record is less likely to trigger a rate change than a pattern of recent claims. You might also be less likely to see a rate increase if your insurance company covers your damages and then successfully recovers that money from the at-fault driver’s insurer. Many carriers treat this as a resolved claim.
Not necessarily. Filing a claim and a rate change are related, but they’re not the same thing. Whether your rate changes after a claim depends on your carrier’s policies, your driving history, the type of accident, and your state. Some carriers don’t raise rates after a first claim, especially if you have a clean record.
Yes. You can switch carriers at any time, even after an accident. Because every carrier prices an accident differently, it can be worth looking for a carrier who specializes in non-standard insurance for drivers with imperfect records. If your current carrier’s rate has gone up significantly, it’s worth seeing what else is available before you accept the increase.



